Browse our menu
Browse everything Cream Valley Custom Cakes has to offer — reach out directly to place an order.
Check back soon — something delicious is on the way.
Meet Machelle Plank
Crafting with love and care, right here in the community. Every product is made by hand in small batches using quality ingredients.
What folks are saying
No reviews yet — be the first.
Ordered from Cream Valley Custom Cakes? We'd love to hear how it went.
Your order number, or the code from the card in your bag.
Cream Valley Custom Cakes
Find your order
Both are in your order confirmation email — the number's in the subject line.
Bought in person? If there was a card in your bag, use its code instead.
Say Hello
Questions, custom orders, or just to chat?
Cream Valley Custom Cakes reads every message and typically replies within a day.
Loading…
Order Placed!
Thank you — check your email for your order confirmation.
🌿 Fresh. Local. Sustainable. Your purchase supports a local food business.
Cream Valley Custom Cakes
Sign in to leave a review
Don't have an account?
By creating an account you agree to Butter & Sage Market's Terms of Service.
Already have an account?
