Custom Order
Baked Goods
Indulge in Caitlyn's Crumb's heavenly Chocolate Chip Cookie Bites from Independence, MO, and make…
With Love Mother just joined the market
Homemade treats made with love just for you
Caitlyn's Crumb
Homemade treats made with love just for you
Bakery
Local maker
20
Products
In rotation
●
Accepting orders
The Menu
Shop everything fresh
Search the catalog, filter by category, save what you love. Pickup options at checkout.
Showing 20 of 20 items
Baked Goods
Two chewy cookies embrace a cloud of silky vanilla frosting in Caitlyn's irresistible creation.…
Baked Goods
Indulge in Caitlyn's Crumb's legendary chocolate chip cookies, handcrafted in Independence and bursting with…
Cookies
Unleash your inner artist with Caitlyn's Crumb's DIY Halloween Cookie Decorating Kits from Independence,…
Baked Goods
Indulge in the ultimate comfort treat with Caitlyn's Crumb's Red Velvet Cookie Sandwich, where…
Baked Goods
Sink your teeth into Caitlyn's Crumb's 30-gram red velvet cookies, brimming with white and…
Baked Goods
Indulge in Caitlyn's Crumb's chocolate chip muffins, bursting with gooey, rich chocolate in every…
Baked Goods
Discover the joy of a morning indulgence with Bakery Style Muffins from Caitlyn's Crumb…
Baked Goods
Savor the burst of sun-ripened blueberries in Caitlyn's bakery-style muffins from Independence, MO—so fluffy,…
Watch it get packaged
Everything is made the day before you get it. Make sure to order at least 48 hours before the day you would like to get your item.
The Maker
Meet Caitlyn Lamb
"Caitlyn Lamb, your local favorite."
Nestled in Independence, MO, Caitlyn's Crumb is your go-to spot for homemade goodness that warms the heart. From freshly baked bread that practically hugs you from the inside out to pastries that make your taste buds dance, everything here is crafted with love and local flair.
Caitlyn treats each loaf like a work of art, and you can taste her dedication in every bite. Whether you're picking up a crusty sourdough for dinner or indulging in a sweet treat just because, you'll feel right at home. Swing by, say hi to Caitlyn, and let her passion for baking brighten your day. Your taste buds and spirit will thank you!
Where
Independence, MO
Customer Love
What folks are saying
No reviews yet — be the first.
Ordered from Caitlyn's Crumb? We'd love to hear how it went.
Your order number, or the code from the card in your bag.
Caitlyn's Crumb
Find your order
Both are in your order confirmation email — the number's in the subject line.
Bought in person? If there was a card in your bag, use its code instead.
Powered by Butter & Sage Market
Say Hello
Questions, custom orders, or just to chat?
Caitlyn's Crumb reads every message and typically replies within a day.
Got Questions?
Frequently Asked Questions
-
Yes! I offer local pick up in Independence, message me to make arrangements!
Loading…
Secure Checkout
Order Placed!
Thank you — check your email for your order confirmation.
Fresh. Local. Sustainable. Your purchase supports a local food business.
Caitlyn's Crumb
Caitlyn's Crumb
Sign in or create an account
Don't have an account?
By creating an account you agree to Butter & Sage Market's Terms of Service.
Already have an account?
